| In The MAC Tournament… |
| 1982 (several sites) |
| First Round: CMU 47, Western Michigan 45 |
| Quarterfinals: Miami 103, CMU 56 |
| |
| *1983 (Oxford, Ohio) |
| Semi-finals: CMU 80, Toledo 66 |
| Championship: CMU 78, Miami 73 |
| |
| *1984 (Rockford, Illinois) |
| Semifinals: CMU 106, Northern Illinois 72 |
| Championship: CMU 71, Toledo 55 |
| |
| 1985 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| Semifinals: CMU 72, Northern Illinois 59 |
| Championship: Western Michigan 73, CMU 63 |
| |
| 1986 (Rockford, Ill.) |
| Semifinals: CMU 67, Bowling Green 64 |
| Championship: Ohio 92, CMU 85 (OT) |
| |
| 1987 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| Semifinals: CMU 82, Western Michigan 70 |
| Championship: Bowling Green 63, CMU 62 |
| |
| 1988 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| First Round |
| (Mount Pleasant): CMU 50, Toledo 49 |
| Semifinals |
| (Toledo, Ohio): Bowling Green 95, CMU 60 |
| |
| 1989 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| First Round (Oxford, Ohio): CMU 74, Miami 58 |
| Semifinals (Toledo, Ohio): Toledo 55, CMU 51 |
| |
| 1990 (Detroit) |
| First Round (Muncie, Ind.): Ball State 77, CMU 57 |
| |
| 1991 (Detroit) |
| First Round (Mount Pleasant): CMU 71, Ohio 70 |
| Semifinals (Detroit): CMU 84, Bowling Green 72 |
| Championship (Detroit): Toledo 93, CMU 66 |
| |
| 1992 (Detroit) |
| First Round (Mount Pleasant): CMU 69, Miami 59 |
| Semifinals (Detroit): Toledo 69, CMU 59 |
| |
| 1993 (Columbus, Ohio) |
| First Round (Kent, Ohio): Kent State 71, CMU 57 |
| |
| 1994 (Columbus, Ohio) |
| First Round (Toledo, Ohio): Toledo 74, CMU 71 |
| |
| 1995 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| First Round (Toledo, Ohio): Toledo 81, CMU 64 |
| |
| 1997 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| First Round (Kent, Ohio): Kent State 106, CMU 63 |
| |
| 1998 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| First Round (Bowling Green, Ohio): BGSU 76, CMU 65 |
| |
| 1999 (Toledo, Ohio) |
| First Round (Toledo, Ohio): Toledo 88, CMU 78 |
| |
| 2000 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Muncie, Ind.): Ball State 95, CMU 81 |
| |
| 2001 (Cleveland,Ohio) |
| First Round (DeKalb, Ill.): NIU 57, CMU 35 |
| |
| 2002 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Kalamazoo, Mich.): WMU 77, CMU 67 |
| |
| 2003 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Buffalo, N.Y.): Buffalo 72, CMU 53 |
| |
| 2004 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Bowling Green, Ohio): BGSU 66, CMU 54 |
| |
| 2005 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Athens, Ohio): Ohio 71, CMU 43 |
| |
| 2006 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Athens, Ohio): Ohio 74, CMU 57 |
| |
| 2007 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Cleveland, Ohio): Ohio 55, CMU 51 |
| |
| 2008 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Cleveland, Ohio): Ohio 68, CMU 65 |
| |
| 2009 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Cleveland, Ohio): CMU 67, Akron 59 |
| Quarterfinals (Cleveland, Ohio): Bowling Green 82, CMU 65 |
| |
| 2010 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Mount Pleasant) CMU 69, Ohio 66 |
| Quarterfinals (Cleveland, Ohio) Kent State 68, CMU 55 |
| |
| 2011 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| Quarterfinals (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 90, Buffalo 69 |
| Semifinals (Cleveland, Ohio) Bowling Green 80, CMU 72 |
| |
| 2012 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| First Round (Mount Pleasant) CMU 86, Ball State 62 |
| Second Round (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 58, Ohio 55 |
| Quarterfinals (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 78, Miami 64 |
| Semifinals (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 69, Bowling Green 66 |
| Championship (Cleveland, Ohio) Eastern Michigan 72, CMU 71 |
| |
| *2013 (Cleveland, Ohio) |
| Quarterfinals (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 81, Bowling Green 48 |
| Semifinals (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 66, Toledo 61 |
| Championship (Cleveland, Ohio) CMU 86, Akron 68 |
| |
| *MAC Champions |
| |
| |
| In the NCAA Tournament… |
| |
| 1983 (College Park, Maryland) |
| First Round: Maryland 94, CMU 71 |
| |
| 1984 (Mount Pleasant) |
| First Round: Alabama 78, CMU 70 |
| |
| 2013 (Columbus, Ohio) |
| First Round: No. 6 Oklahoma 78, No. 11 CMU 73 |
| |
| In the WNIT... |
| |
| 2011 (Normal, Ill.) |
| First Round: Illinois State 72, CMU 59 |
| |
| 2012 (Normal, Ill.) |
| First Round: Illinois State 69, CMU 68 |
|
